Private schools say abolition would be vote-loser

School corridor

Private-school leaders are warning that attempts to abolish their schools will prove to be a “vote-loser”.

Labour has backed plans for private schools to lose tax benefits and be “integrated” into the state sector.

But Fiona Boulton, chairwoman of the Headmasters’ and Headmistresses’ Conference (HMC), said that shutting down private schools was “based on ignorance and the desire to damage”.

Labour said children’s life chances should not depend on parental wealth.


The challenge from the HMC comes as it begins its annual conference in London.

It follows Labour’s decision to close down the independent school sector – including calls for their assets to be “redistributed”.

There has been an angry reaction from private-school leaders – and Mrs Boulton, head of Guildford High School, will tell the conference that Labour has misjudged the public mood.

  • Could Labour really ban private schools?
  • Labour calls to redistribute assets of private schools
  • Private school and Oxbridge take top jobs

The HMC will publish its own survey findings, a ComRes poll of more than 2,000 people in England, Wales and Scotland, showing 68% support the principle of parents being able to pay for private education.

“This tells us that the policy of destroying great independent schools is a vote-loser,” Mrs Boulton will say.

Angela RaynerImage copyrightPA MEDIA
Image captionAngela Rayner told private schools that they would lose tax benefits under a Labour government

“The political activists who want to tax good schools to death without a notion of how to nurture achievement elsewhere, do not understand the common sense of the British people.”

She will tell the conference of private school leaders that “independence and choice are concepts which never go out of fashion”.

‘Abolition by back door’

A Labour spokesman rejected the criticism from the private schools, saying: “Of course the establishment will try to defend its privileges.”

But the party appears to have pulled back from suggestions of seizing private school assets.

Shadow chancellor John McDonnell last week played down what he called “draconian measures”.

“Everything will be done on the basis of consultation – and often this isn’t about seizing property, it’s about having access to services and facilities,” he said.

But there is still a commitment to removing charitable status and any tax advantages – with Labour arguing that fee-charging schools should “pay their taxes like the rest of us”.

Mrs Boulton will say that adding such taxes would be “abolition by the back door”.

“It would ensure that many independent schools would not survive and others will become more expensive.”

Independent schools have argued that if they were put out of business, it would mean state schools would have to find funding and places for those extra pupils.

But shadow education secretary Angela Rayner has told private school leaders that a Labour government’s first budget would “immediately end the tax breaks gifted to private schools”.

“We will end the absurd situation where every state school pays business rates but schools like Eton do not,” said Ms Rayner.

“It is wrong that children’s life chances are determined by how wealthy their parents are,” she said.


About The Author

Related Posts